All Indian companies are required to conduct mandatory audits under the corporations Act of 2013. An internal auditor is someone who is appointed by the management of the Company and might also be an employee of the Company. An external auditor can never be an employee of the Company and should be independent of the Company/entity they are auditing. As an aspiring auditor or finance professional, it’s essential to understand both internal and statutory audits since they form the foundation of audit practices in organizations. Gaining practical exposure to both will enhance your skills and broaden your career opportunities in the field of finance and auditing. For example, the internal audit team may conduct a review of XYZ’s accounts payable process to ensure that invoices are being processed accurately and in a timely manner.
Internal audits are typically conducted on a regular basis, such as quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. They may likewise be called upon to survey the planning system for unique tasks or to audit internal cycles. It may concentrate on a single process (such as procure-to-pay or order-to-cash) or several processes, productivity, fraud detection, or the application of policies. Treelife’s multidisciplinary team has the right domain expertise in the startup ecosystem and can provide you with the necessary insights and guidance to make the right decisions for your business and auditing requirements. KPMG’s low score on Trustpilot reflects a small sample of mostly individual users, with just 46 reviews. While some comments recognise the firm’s strong reputation and global brand, many mention high pricing.
The primary goal of an internal audit is to identify areas of improvement, ensure compliance with internal policies, and add value to the organization’s overall performance. On the other hand, Statutory Audit is an independent audit of a company’s financial statements and accounting records conducted by a licensed and qualified auditor. In the case of XYZ, a statutory audit would be conducted by an external auditor who is appointed by the shareholders of the company. On the other hand, a statutory audit is conducted by an external auditor who is independent of the company and reports to the shareholders. The purpose of a statutory audit is to provide assurance to the company’s shareholders, lenders, and other stakeholders that the financial statements of the company present a true and fair view of its financial position.
Statutory audit and review requirements
Grant Thornton is a smart choice for businesses expanding regionally or managing operations across Greater China, especially those in sectors like logistics, hospitality, or manufacturing. Many employees mention strong mentorship, learning opportunities, and a collaborative culture. As with many mid-sized firms, experiences can vary by office or region, but the overall sentiment suggests a solid platform for professional development. While some employees appreciate the exposure to diverse clients and industries, the reviews suggest a mixed experience overall. Many reviewers highlight the firm’s strong brand, learning opportunities, and exposure to large clients.
Legal & Policies
An internal auditor aims to examine whether a company hascommitted any error or fraud and rectifies it in time. It is also important to note that a number of privatefirms provide statutory audit services to their clients. Audits are typically performed by certified public accountants (CPAs) or other qualified auditors who are trained to examine financial records and operations. Organizations may need audits for a variety of reasons, such as complying with regulatory requirements, attracting investors, obtaining loans, or improving internal controls. The scope of a statutory audit is determined by the regulatory body or government agency that requires the audit.
Internal audit reports are prepared for management, while statutory audit reports are prepared for the stakeholders, such as shareholders, investors, and lenders. This guide provides an overview of the differences between the two types of audits, including the scope and objectives of each. After the audit is completed, reports are generated for management, outlining findings and recommendations. These insights are crucial for driving improvements in the organization’s operations, ensuring ongoing compliance and operational excellence. In conclusion, Internal Audit is an important function in a listed company that provides assurance to management, the board of directors, and shareholders that the company’s operations. BDO is a strong choice for mid-sized businesses that need high-quality audits aligned with international standards but tailored to local requirements.
Limited assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material errors or fraud. A reasonable or high level of assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material errors or fraud. When it comes to Statutory Audit, the scope of the work andresponsibilities are determined by law. On the other hand, the scope of work ofInternal Auditors is determined by the management of your company.
Professional
Both audits serve distinct purposes, but together they play a vital role in maintaining the integrity and accountability of a company’s financial reporting. Understanding the difference between internal audit vs statutory audit is crucial for businesses to ensure effective governance and compliance. While both audits play essential roles in evaluating a company’s operations and financial records, they differ significantly in objectives, scope, frequency, and legal requirements. In this blog, we’ll explore the key distinctions between internal and statutory audits to help you grasp their unique roles and importance in an organization’s financial framework. Despite their differences, statutory and internal audits are both crucial to a company’s operational and financial framework. Both internal and statutory audits play crucial roles in maintaining a company’s financial health and integrity.
- Evaluation of RiskInternal audits emphasise risk protection and mitigation across a range of corporate functions, with a focus on analysing risks to meet organisational objectives.
- BDO is a strong choice for mid-sized businesses that need high-quality audits aligned with international standards but tailored to local requirements.
- On the other hand, the scope of work ofInternal Auditors is determined by the management of your company.
- Statutory audits, on the other hand, are designed to guarantee the integrity of financial statements, adherence to legal requirements, and safeguarding the interests of stakeholders.
- In the context of financial management and corporate governance, audits are essential for guaranteeing efficiency, accountability, and openness.
- The objective is to identify inefficiencies, risks, and compliance gaps, allowing management to take corrective actions.
Internal audits are typically conducted periodically, often annually or semi-annually, but the frequency can vary based on the organization’s needs and risk assessment. As with many professional services firms, Grant Thornton’s typical clients are corporations and businesses, not individual consumers, making platforms like Trustpilot not really relevant. Forvis Mazars is well-suited for mid-sized companies and international subsidiaries in sectors like manufacturing, tech, or professional services that require audit compliance across multiple jurisdictions. Forvis Mazars Hong Kong is a leading provider of corporate finance and advisory services with a strong emphasis on quality, transparency, and international coordination. It is part of the newly formed global network Forvis Mazars, established through the combination of established firms Mazars and FORVIS in 2024. Next, let’s take a look at firms that, although they may not have the global scale of the Big Four, are well-established in Hong Kong and offer reliable audit services with a more personalised approach.
- An external auditor can never be an employee of the Company and should be independent of the Company/entity they are auditing.
- Despite their differences, statutory and internal audits are both crucial to a company’s operational and financial framework.
- Many reviewers highlight the firm’s strong brand, learning opportunities, and exposure to large clients.
- It is part of the newly formed global network Forvis Mazars, established through the combination of established firms Mazars and FORVIS in 2024.
Let’s take the example of a multinational company XYZ to understand the difference between Internal Audit and Statutory Audit.
How often are internal and statutory audits conducted?
Internal Audit is focused on evaluating and improving the effectiveness of an organization’s risk management, control, and governance processes. Statutory Audit, on the other hand, is focused on providing an opinion on the accuracy and reliability of a company’s financial statements. Internal Audit is a function that evaluates and improves the effectiveness of an organization’s risk management, control, and governance processes. In the case of XYZ, the internal audit team would be responsible for reviewing the company’s operations and financial systems to identify areas of risk and recommend controls and process improvements. In a listed company, Statutory Audit is required by law and plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of financial reporting and ensuring that investors have access to accurate and reliable financial information. The Statutory Audit is conducted by an external auditor who is appointed by the shareholders of the company.
Internal Audit vs. Statutory Audit: Understanding the Key Differences
The internal audit’s scope is broad and may cover, among other things, operational procedures, the risk management system, and adherence to the company’s internal policies in addition to financial reporting. Internal auditors can evaluate anything from the security of IT systems to HR procedures. The main objective of a statutory audit is to deliver an independent opinion on the organization’s financial statements. This opinion assures stakeholders—including shareholders, investors, and lenders—that the financial statements are accurate and reliable.
Both documentation and documentationReports on internal audits include thorough analyses and suggestions for the organization’s internal use. On the other hand, statutory audit reports are thorough records that are provided to shareholders and regulatory bodies, offering an open picture of the company’s financial situation and compliance level. In summary, internal audit and statutory audit serve different purposes and have different objectives, scope, audience, and frequency. While they both provide assurance on an organization’s financial records, they differ in their level of independence, level of detail, and cost. Organizations should carefully consider their needs and requirements before deciding which type of audit to conduct. Internal audits focus on improving internal controls and operational efficiency, while statutory audits verify the accuracy and fairness of financial statements for external stakeholders.
The primary purpose of an audit report is to provide stakeholders—such as shareholders, investors, and lenders—with assurance that an organization’s financial statements are accurate and complete. The frequency of audits depends on the difference between statutory audit and internal audit organization’s needs and regulatory requirements. Internal audits may be conducted on a regular basis, such as quarterly, semi-annually, or annually, while statutory audits are typically conducted annually. The scope of an internal audit is determined by the organization’s internal audit department. It can cover all aspects of an organization’s operations, including financial, operational, and compliance areas. By understanding the significance of internal audits, organizations can better leverage these evaluations to enhance their financial integrity and operational efficiency.
The scope of internal audit is determined by the organization’s objectives, risks, and priorities. Internal auditors have access to all areas of the organization and can review financial and non-financial information. They may perform detailed testing and analysis, including interviews with employees, review of documents, and examination of processes and controls. As per the provision of the Company Act, you need tocarry out Statutory Audit to ensure that all the financial details of yourcompany are credible without any misstatement or discrepancies.
In an internal audit, the auditor is usually an employee of the organization or a consultant hired by the organization. While they are expected to be objective and independent, there may be potential conflicts of interest, such as a fear of losing their job or a desire to please their employer. On the other hand, in a statutory audit, the auditor is an independent third party who is appointed by a regulatory body or government agency. They are required to adhere to strict ethical and professional standards, and are expected to be completely objective and independent in their examination of the financial statements. Internal audits enhance operational efficiency and internal controls, while statutory audits provide an independent assessment of financial statements, promoting transparency and stakeholder confidence. Organizations don’t typically choose between internal and statutory audits, as each serves a distinct purpose and offers unique benefits.
It suggests a varied employee experience, with some valuing the brand and career development opportunities, while others may find the work environment challenging. While the score is low, most comments come from individuals with isolated touchpoints—such as job applicants or those seeking one-off support—so the reviews don’t reflect the views of PwC’s long-term or corporate clients. Whether you’re an SME approaching mandatory audit thresholds or looking for a more strategic audit partner, this ranked list will help you make a confident, informed decision for your business. While Statutory Auditors are independent employees from an independentbody, Internal Auditors are part of the workforce of a company. Even though it is required that Statutory Auditors must be certifiedchartered accountants, this provision does not apply to Internal Auditors asthe management may appoint individuals it considers fit for the job.